According to a report in the Philadelphia Inquirer, the Philadelphia Phillies are scheduled to announce on Wednesday the acquisition of pitcher Roy Halladay from the Toronto Blue Jay at Citizens Bank Park.
The blockbuster and complicated trade involving four teams - Toronto, Philadelphia, Seattle Mariners and Oakland Athletics - features two of the best pitchers in baseball changing teams and swapping leagues, as well, it officially paves the way for the rebuilding effort now clearly underway in Toronto.
Multiple reports indicate that the Blue Jays will receive the following package of players from the Phillies for Halladay: righthander Kyle Drabek, outfielder Michael Taylor and backstop Travis d'Arnaud. The Blue Jays would then ship Michael Taylor to the Athletics for first baseman Brett Wallace.
There were many moving pieces to make this trade a reality, the least of which was the Phillies and Halladay agreeing to a contract extension on Tuesday evening.
The Phillies agreed in principal with Halladay to a contract extension on Tuesday evening that extends the best pitcher in baseball for $60-million (all currencies U.S.) through to the 2013 season.
General manager Ruben Amaro Jr. had long coveted Halladay, and was deeply engaged in talks to acquire the pitcher in July. But then-Blue Jays GM J.P. Ricciardi requested Drabek, Happ, and highly touted outfield prospects Domonic Brown and Anthony Gose, and talks collapsed. By not including Happ, Brown, and Gose in this trade, Amaro negotiated a lower price in December than he was able to in July.
The second-tier prospects used to acquire Lee must also be considered part of the price for Halladay. On July 29, the Phillies sent four minor-league prospects, pitchers Carlos Carrasco and Jason Knapp, catcher Lou Marson, and infielder Jason Donald, to the Cleveland Indians for Lee. The trade was made possible by Cleveland's need to shed payroll.
When word leaked before the Baseball Winter Meetings that Halladay would exercise his no-trade clause if a deal wasn't consummated by Spring Training, the deck was effectively stacked against in-coming Blue Jays general manager Alex Anthopoulos.
Whether this deal turns out closer to the one that sent David Cone to the New York Yankees for Marty Janzen, Mike Gordon and Jason Jarvis, remains to be seen. However, Drabek clearly needs to be an impact pitcher for this deal to be considered a wash at best.
Do you agree with the Toronto Blue Jays decision to trade Roy Halladay?
Yes, a rebuilding (and a new focus) was in order after eight years of mis-management.
No, I think the Blue Jays are close to contending and would have preferred the organization increase the payroll to $120-million and take my chances with "Doc" Halladay in the rotation.
What say you Fadoo?
Phils set to introduce pitcher Halladay [Philadelphia Inquirer]





Chris wrote on Dec 17, 2009
Somehow Toronto teams always seem to come out the l o s e r s on every trade. Throwing in $6 mil cash is ridiculous. It should have been Halladay straight up for those prospects or no deal. I question the merits of going to Philly (especially since they lost Cliff Lee). Philly will be no better next year than they were this year - which isn't good enough to beat the Yankees. I think "Doc" picked the wrong team, but time will tell I guess. As for the Jays, I'm done watching. I've seen 10 years of rebuilding ballclubs and it makes for dreadfully uninspiring television. This team has no plan for the future and they won't spend money to win so their fortunes will never change. If Drabek turns into a star, he'll be traded away someday too.Terence wrote on Dec 17, 2009
I agree with your take Eddie, the $6-million sticks out like a sore thumb! You would have thought that by forwarding the Phillies cash, which ain't chump change, that the Blue Jays would have received maybe another prospect in the deal. Just saying...EddyinChina wrote on Dec 17, 2009
Trading Doc sucks balls..... His performance will be missed, but more so and something I think is being over looked is leadership in the club house, he was a class act all around... There is one part of the deal that drives me crazy.... sending 6 mil to Philly for his salary... That is Nucking Futs, here take please take the best picture in baseball and 6 mill towards his salary..... get real..... Signed a new Philly FanLinden16 wrote on Dec 16, 2009
I've got no problem with this trade. I'd rather see the Jays do a complete re-build, instead of continuing to flounder along. Attendance may take a hit this year, but the fans will rally behind a s***py team of youngsters. Market it as such, and see how it goes. Nobody in Toronto has pockets deep enough to compete with Boston or NYY, so trying to promote the Jays as winners just ain't gonna happen. Hopefully, this year's squad will be hungry and will play some entertaining ball - that's enough for me, at least...Steve wrote on Dec 16, 2009
Are you serious? To play in a meaningful game is cir***stantial as the Blue Jays under Ricciardi's tenure were never quite good enough to compete with the free spending New York Yankees and Boston Red Sox to get to the post season. Doc's numbers stand up to any of the top end pitchers in the game.jeffy1199 wrote on Dec 16, 2009
I am tired of hearing him called "the best pitcher in baseball". Halladay has never pitched a meaningful game. lets see how he plays under the pressure of the post season before we call him the best.Steve wrote on Dec 16, 2009
I agree with Bob and think the decision to trade Halladay was not the correct move going forward. The Toronto market is the fourth largest in North America and the Blue Jays fan base needs to see Rogers Communications treat the ball club as a big market player. Clearly it would be difficult to get fair market value for Halladay, but faced with the prospect of potentially losing him at the end of the season for picks or trading him, Rogers Communications should have stepped up and committed the big $$$ and taken their chances at the end of the season to resign him. Blue Jays fans needed to be shown the organization was serious, clearly they're not.YukonSloMo wrote on Dec 16, 2009
A very, very sad day for baseball in Toronto...