CBS's Super Bowl coverage was much like the game itself: Well played, occasionally exciting and, except for an interception, largely error free.
The telecast may have focused too much on Indianapolis Colts quarterback Peyton Manning, but he really was the story going into the game and for most of it, despite throwing an interception late and losing to the New Orleans Saints.
The production: CBS's 50 cameras were used effectively for the most part. Nothing was missed, although the overhead Cablecam was over-used. It helped the telecast that CBS posts the time clock on the screen, allowing the viewer to see how close to the edge Manning was operating with the no-huddle offense. In the fourth quarter, CBS's replay cameras gave us a good look at the disputed two point conversation that was given to the Saints in a review. The fast SuperVision cameras didn't bring anything exceptional to the telecast.
Announcer Jim Nantz: He delivered a solid, unobtrusive play by play that never got in the way of the action on the field. His call is clear and straight-forward. He was criticized, correctly, for doing a commercial earlier in the season with Manning. It left the impression that he's a pal of Manning and may favour him in the game telecasts. Several times he referred to Manning as "Peyton," although he never called Saints quarterback Drew Brees "Drew." But Manning ranks among the few athletes whose first name is enough, like Kobe, A-Rod or LeBron.
Nantz described most of the big moments well and with few words. When the Saints succeeded in their on-side kick, he said simply and accurately, "What a fearless way to start the second half."
Phil Simms: He doesn't criticize and rarely expresses an opinion, which makes his game analysis somewhat soft and uninteresting. When Colts receiver Pierre Garcon dropped a perfectly thrown ball in the second quarter, Simms didn't attempt to discuss why or say something like, "You've got make those catches in the big games." Nantz stepped in to say the dropped ball was a "momentum changer, perhaps."
Still, Simms's strength is his analysis. He noted the Colts defense hadn't faced a passing offense like the Saints' for several weeks – the Jets and Ravens in the post-season didn't pass much. He also got it right late in the first half when he predicted that New Orleans would go for the touchdown with fourth and one at the Saints one yard line. In advance of the Saints being stopped, he stated that going for the TD was the wrong decision, that they should kick the field goal.
Studio analysts: Loud, irritating and often stupid.
Halftime show: No, you weren't watching Saturday night entertainment at the home, but the Who is looking a little old. Still, Roger Daltrey's voice is holding up pretty well. (He's 65.) The show, featuring a medley of hits, wasn't in the same league as Bruce Springteen and the E Street Band a year ago, but the Boss delivered the best the Super Bowl halftime entertainment ever.
The Burke story
It's worth wondering what U.S. television will do with the death of Toronto Maple Leaf general manager Brian Burke's son, Brendan, particularly during the Winter Olympics, when Burke will be front and centre as manager of the U.S. men's hockey team.
Who knows how mawkish this story might get. We saw a bit of it Sunday in Toronto where The Toronto Star headline read, "Leafs win one for Brendan," and the headline on The Globe and Mail online edition read, "Leafs win one for Brian Burke."
The Star, by the way, posted the following when the news of Brendan's death in an automobile accident broke: "Brendan Burke – the gay son of Leaf general manager Brian Burke – has been killed in a car accident in Indiana." It was eventually changed to: "Brendan Burke – the youngest son of Leaf general manager Brian Burke – has been killed in a car accident in Indiana."
Unfortunately, this story is red meat for a tabloid producer. Just imagine the maudlin pieces that could surface during the Olympics: Burke wants to win one for son. Brian perseveres despite family grief . The tragic story of Brendan and Brian, the son comes out at Thanksgiving, Brian supports him and then this.
Let's hope the Olympic networks show restraint.
Other thoughts
Couldn't agree more with Hockey Night In Canada's Don Cherry: Steve Stamkos deserves a spot on the Canadian Olympic team. Grapes pointed out that over the past 82 games, Alex Ovechkin leads in the NHL with 54 goals, followed by Sidney Crosby with 49. And in third place? Stamkos, with 47 goals. Canada, which always seems to struggle offensively in high level international events, could use his goal scoring.
Hockey Night's Mike Milbury had it right to rap Atlanta Trasher general manager Don Waddell for his handling of the Ilya Kovalchuk deal. How can you not allow an interested team access to Kovalchuk to see if he'll sign long term? If an understanding had been reached, his value would have gone up.
For more blogs from William Houston, go to www.truthandrumours.net




YukonSloMo wrote on Feb 9, 2010
I concur...some things are best left UNSAID...The Superbowl was pretty darn good..The halftime show....zzzzzzz sorrry at 65....Daltrey or not...relevance!? The could have rocked the house wht the Black Eyed Peas....Stamkos....the kids has game....what about Barry Melrose..that maroon...Ilya..who cares....talent or not....what has he done.....Playoffs, Cup Final...leader of men...how about glutton...go away....say to the KHL...Larry P wrote on Feb 8, 2010
Thanks for calling out the Star on that horrible deadline. I expect that from the Sun. I guess I now know that idiots can work at any publication